Robert Smalls
Robert Smalls: Counted Out
When Robert Smalls lost a disputed election by 532 votes in 1886, what did the official investigation actually find — and where did its own members disagree?
6 chapters · 14 min
Chapters
- A seat fought over, year after year. Smalls held his House seat, but almost never without a fight.
- The count. A margin of 532 votes, and a demand for the underlying returns.
- How votes were kept off the rolls. Registration law, used as a gate.
- “The seventh or ‘black’ district”. A dissent that named the district’s design, and quoted a Democratic paper celebrating the result.
- A bribery charge, and crowds at the polls. The majority’s case against Smalls, in its own words.
- “Not elected… and is entitled to his seat”. The committee’s verdict, more than two years after the election.
Sources
- Men of mark; eminent, progressive and rising, Internet Archive
- Tillman vs. Smalls. Papers in the case of Tillman vs. Smalls, Fifth District South Carolina. November 9, 1877. -- Ordered to be printed, Library of Congress (LOC)
- Tillman vs. Smalls, Fifth Congressional District of South Carolina. June 8, 1878. -- Laid on the table and ordered to be printed, Library of Congress (LOC)
- Smalls vs. Tillman. Testimony and papers in the contested election case of Robert Smalls vs. George D. Tillman from the Fifth Congressional District of South Ca, Library of Congress (LOC)
- Smalls vs. Tillman. June 29, 1882. -- Ordered to be printed, Library of Congress (LOC)
- Robert Smalls vs. William Elliott. December 7, 1888. -- Referred to the House Calendar and ordered to be printed, Library of Congress (LOC)