Port Chicago, 1944
Port Chicago, 1944: The Long Appeal
How did the Navy respond to the appeals of the Port Chicago men, and why did it take eighty years to clear their names?
6 chapters · 12 min
Chapters
- “Whenever more than one Negro disobeys”. Thurgood Marshall took the case to the Navy’s lawyers in Washington and argued that the record, read at face value, did not show a mutiny.
- Sent back to the court. The Navy agreed that the court had heard evidence it should not have, sent the case back, and the same court convicted the men again.
- Two years, or three. After the war ended, the Navy cut the sentences sharply but kept the convictions, and early in 1946 it sent the men back to duty.
- Equality of treatment. The Navy began to change who did its most dangerous work, and in 1948 the President ordered equal treatment across the armed forces.
- Reviewed and upheld. Congress ordered the Navy to look again at the case and named the site a national memorial, and the Navy looked again and upheld the convictions.
- “I am afraid to load ammunition”. One of the fifty asked a President for a pardon in his own words, and eighty years after the explosion the Navy cleared them all.
Sources
- Statement of Thurgood Marshall before the Office of the Judge Advocate General, 3 April 1945, in the court-martial case file of Julius J. Allen et al., National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Acting Secretary of the Navy to the Commandant, Twelfth Naval District, returning the record of Julius J. Allen et al. to the court, 17 May 1945, National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Captain H. E. Stassen to the Secretary of the Navy, “The Ammunition Handlers’ Mutiny – Court Martial Case of ALLEN, Julius J. and 49 Others,” 15 October 1945, approved by James Forrestal, 16 October 1945, National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Chief of Naval Personnel, recommendation on the sentences in revision, approved 20 November 1945, in the court-martial case file, National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Petition for Pardon for Seaman Second Class Freddie Meeks, United States Navy, 20 May 1999, National Archives, Clinton Presidential Library (FOIA 2006-1704-F)
- Executive Order 9981, Establishing the President’s Committee on Equality of Treatment and Opportunity in the Armed Services, 26 July 1948, National Archives, General Records of the U.S. Government (RG 11)
- National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Years 1992 and 1993, Public Law 102-190, sec. 552, “Review of Port Chicago court-martial cases,” 105 Stat. 1371, U.S. Government Publishing Office, GovInfo
- Public Law 102-562, Title II, “Port Chicago National Memorial Act of 1992,” 106 Stat. 4235, U.S. Government Publishing Office, GovInfo
- “The Mutiny Trial,” Port Chicago Naval Magazine National Memorial, National Park Service
- “Places,” Port Chicago Naval Magazine National Memorial, National Park Service