Port Chicago, 1944
Port Chicago, 1944: The Refusal and the Trial
Why did 258 survivors of the Port Chicago explosion refuse to load ammunition, and how did fifty of them come to be convicted of mutiny?
6 chapters · 13 min
Chapters
- Three weeks after. The men who survived the blast were moved, kept together and, three weeks later, sent to load another ship.
- August 9. When the order came to load the ship, most of the men refused, and they gave the same reason again and again: they were afraid.
- The admiral’s warning. Admiral Wright told the men that refusing could cost them their lives, and the group shrank to fifty.
- Fifty on trial. The Navy tried all fifty men together on one charge of mutiny, and the case turned on whether a shared fear could be called a conspiracy.
- Every one of them testified. All fifty accused men took the stand, and their stories were simple, specific and mostly the same.
- Eighty minutes. The court found all fifty guilty after a short deliberation, and the admiral who had warned them approved the sentences.
Sources
- General Courts Martial Case File of Julius J. Allen et al., “The Port Chicago Mutiny” (1944–1945), National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Commandant, Twelfth Naval District (C. H. Wright) to the Secretary of the Navy, “Refusal of enlisted personnel to handle ammunition,” 12 August 1944, National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- “Summary of Testimony in the Case of Julius J. Allen, Seaman Second Class, U.S. Naval Reserve, et al., Tried by General Court Martial at San Francisco, 14 Sept. 1944 – 24 Oct. 1944”, National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Testimony of Commander Joseph R. Tobin, record of proceedings, general court martial of Julius J. Allen et al., National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Commandant, Twelfth Naval District, action of the convening authority, Docket No. 2001, 15 November 1944, National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Brief and statement of Thurgood Marshall, counsel for the accused, before the Office of the Judge Advocate General, 3 April 1945, National Archives, Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General (Navy) (RG 125)
- Special Court of Inquiry into the Port Chicago Explosion, Volume VIII (October 1944), National Archives (RG 181)
- “The Mutiny Trial,” Port Chicago Naval Magazine National Memorial, National Park Service