The Silent Protest Parade of 1917

Why would ten thousand people march down Fifth Avenue and say nothing at all?

12 chapters · 24 min

Chapters

  1. A Strike, Then a Mob. The East St. Louis massacre began as a labor dispute and became days of mob killing that the police did little to stop.
  2. A Crowd, and a Sign That Read ‘Union Service’. A photograph taken in the street during the massacre shows an ordinary commercial block, a crowd, and no visible police control.
  3. Reporting the Losses. In the massacre’s aftermath, Black East St. Louis residents lined up at a relief station to report what the mob had taken from them.
  4. A Pattern, Not an Isolated Case. East St. Louis was the immediate trigger for the parade, but organizers pointed to a documented pattern of lynching the NAACP had already been tracking for years.
  5. Johnson Chooses Silence. James Weldon Johnson and a group of Harlem church leaders first considered a rally at Carnegie Hall, then chose a silent march instead.
  6. The Committee. The march was organized by a specific, named committee of clergy and civic leaders, not by the NAACP alone.
  7. Why We March. Organizers printed a leaflet explaining the march in their own words, and police forced the removal of one banner before it began.
  8. Children First, Then White, Then Dark Suits. The march’s order and dress were chosen deliberately: children leading, women in white behind them, men in dark suits or uniforms last, to a muffled drumbeat.
  9. Fifth Avenue Watches. More than 20,000 spectators lined Fifth Avenue, and the next day’s papers described the march in strikingly similar terms.
  10. Du Bois Goes to East St. Louis. After the march, Du Bois and fellow investigator Martha Gruening went to East St. Louis and published what they found.
  11. Wilson Does Not Meet Them. A prearranged NAACP delegation to the White House was turned away, and the federal anti-lynching law organizers wanted did not come for over a century.
  12. What the Silence Started. The Silent Parade became a template other marches returned to for more than a century, right up to a federal law passed 105 years later.

Sources