The Silent Protest Parade of 1917
Why would ten thousand people march down Fifth Avenue and say nothing at all?
12 chapters · 24 min
Chapters
- A Strike, Then a Mob. The East St. Louis massacre began as a labor dispute and became days of mob killing that the police did little to stop.
- A Crowd, and a Sign That Read ‘Union Service’. A photograph taken in the street during the massacre shows an ordinary commercial block, a crowd, and no visible police control.
- Reporting the Losses. In the massacre’s aftermath, Black East St. Louis residents lined up at a relief station to report what the mob had taken from them.
- A Pattern, Not an Isolated Case. East St. Louis was the immediate trigger for the parade, but organizers pointed to a documented pattern of lynching the NAACP had already been tracking for years.
- Johnson Chooses Silence. James Weldon Johnson and a group of Harlem church leaders first considered a rally at Carnegie Hall, then chose a silent march instead.
- The Committee. The march was organized by a specific, named committee of clergy and civic leaders, not by the NAACP alone.
- Why We March. Organizers printed a leaflet explaining the march in their own words, and police forced the removal of one banner before it began.
- Children First, Then White, Then Dark Suits. The march’s order and dress were chosen deliberately: children leading, women in white behind them, men in dark suits or uniforms last, to a muffled drumbeat.
- Fifth Avenue Watches. More than 20,000 spectators lined Fifth Avenue, and the next day’s papers described the march in strikingly similar terms.
- Du Bois Goes to East St. Louis. After the march, Du Bois and fellow investigator Martha Gruening went to East St. Louis and published what they found.
- Wilson Does Not Meet Them. A prearranged NAACP delegation to the White House was turned away, and the federal anti-lynching law organizers wanted did not come for over a century.
- What the Silence Started. The Silent Parade became a template other marches returned to for more than a century, right up to a federal law passed 105 years later.
Sources
- Silent Parade, Wikipedia, cross-checked against the New York Times, the NAACP, and Library of Congress primary sources cited in the article
- Silent Protest parade on Fifth Avenue, New York City, July 28, 1917, New York Public Library, Schomburg Center, via Digital Public Library of America
- Silent protest parade in New York (City) against the East St. Louis riots, 1917, Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division
- The Crisis, Volume 14, Issue 5, NAACP, edited by W. E. B. Du Bois, via Wikimedia Commons
- Fire near the East St. Louis Public Library at Eighth Street and Broadway during the race riot, via Wikimedia Commons
- James Weldon Johnson, half-length portrait at desk with telephone, Library of Congress, via Wikimedia Commons