Mendez v. Westminster

Mendez v. Westminster: The Appeal and the Repeal

The Orange County districts appealed the 1946 judgment. What exactly did the Ninth Circuit decide in 1947, what did California change that June, and what do the records show about the case’s reach?

6 chapters · 18 min

Chapters

  1. Three hundred children at Lincoln. Six months after the judgment, a father in El Modeno swore that nothing had changed, and the districts asked the court to put its order on hold.
  2. Friends of the court. National groups filed briefs in the appeal, and some asked the judges to rule against segregation itself.
  3. What the appeals court held. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the judgment, but on narrower ground than the trial judge had used.
  4. What it left open. The appeals court declined the invitation to rule on segregation itself, and one judge wrote separately in harsher words.
  5. Chapter 737. Two months after the ruling, California repealed the two sections of its school code that had allowed separate schools for Indian and Asian children.
  6. What the records show next. The ruling and the repeal changed the law, but the practice went on in places, and the case’s later influence is easy to overstate.

Sources