Mendez v. Westminster
Mendez v. Westminster: The Appeal and the Repeal
The Orange County districts appealed the 1946 judgment. What exactly did the Ninth Circuit decide in 1947, what did California change that June, and what do the records show about the case’s reach?
6 chapters · 18 min
Chapters
- Three hundred children at Lincoln. Six months after the judgment, a father in El Modeno swore that nothing had changed, and the districts asked the court to put its order on hold.
- Friends of the court. National groups filed briefs in the appeal, and some asked the judges to rule against segregation itself.
- What the appeals court held. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the judgment, but on narrower ground than the trial judge had used.
- What it left open. The appeals court declined the invitation to rule on segregation itself, and one judge wrote separately in harsher words.
- Chapter 737. Two months after the ruling, California repealed the two sections of its school code that had allowed separate schools for Indian and Asian children.
- What the records show next. The ruling and the repeal changed the law, but the practice went on in places, and the case’s later influence is easy to overstate.
Sources
- Affidavit for Citation of Alexander M. Lievanos, filed September 27, 1946, Gonzalo Mendez et al. v. Westminster School District of Orange County et al., No. 4292-M, U.S. District Court, Southern District of California, Central Division, Civil Case Files, Records of District Courts of the United States (RG 21), National Archives at Riverside, National Archives
- Order to Show Cause and Affidavit in re Contempt, September 27, 1946, Gonzalo Mendez et al. v. Westminster School District of Orange County et al., No. 4292-M, U.S. District Court, Southern District of California, Central Division, Civil Case Files, Records of District Courts of the United States (RG 21), National Archives at Riverside, National Archives
- Notice of Motion to Obtain Stay of Execution Pending Decision on Appeal, filed October 8, 1946, Gonzalo Mendez et al. v. Westminster School District of Orange County et al., No. 4292-M, U.S. District Court, Southern District of California, Central Division, Civil Case Files, Records of District Courts of the United States (RG 21), National Archives at Riverside, National Archives
- Westminster School District of Orange County v. Mendez, 161 F.2d 774 (9th Cir. 1947), opinion of Circuit Judge Stephens, with a concurring opinion by Circuit Judge Denman, April 14, 1947, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- Motion and Brief for the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People as Amicus Curiae (Thurgood Marshall, Robert L. Carter, Loren Miller), Westminster School District v. Mendez, No. 11,310, U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, filed October 2, 1946, Case Files, RG 276, National Archives, Pacific Sierra Region, San Bruno, California, Internet Archive
- Brief for the American Jewish Congress as Amicus Curiae (Will Maslow, Pauli Murray; Alexander H. Pekelis, special advisor), Westminster School District v. Mendez, No. 11,310, U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, filed October 17, 1946, Case Files, RG 276, National Archives, Pacific Sierra Region, San Bruno, California, Internet Archive
- Carey McWilliams, “Is Your Name Gonzales?”, The Nation 164, no. 11 (March 15, 1947), Internet Archive
- “An act to repeal Sections 8003 and 8004 of the Education Code, relating to the establishment of separate schools for certain races,” Statutes of California 1947, chapter 737, p. 1792, approved by the Governor June 14, 1947, California State Assembly, Office of the Chief Clerk
- Proclamation by the Governor convening the Legislature in First Extraordinary Session, signed Earl Warren, Governor of California, January 9, 1947, Statutes of California 1947, First Extraordinary Session, California State Assembly, Office of the Chief Clerk
- W. Henry Cooke, “The Segregation of Mexican-American School Children in Southern California,” School and Society 67, no. 1745 (June 5, 1948), Internet Archive
- Order to File Mandate of Court of Appeals, February 25, 1949, with the mandate of the Ninth Circuit, Gonzalo Mendez et al. v. Westminster School District of Orange County et al., No. 4292-M, U.S. District Court, Southern District of California, Central Division, Civil Case Files, Records of District Courts of the United States (RG 21), National Archives at Riverside, National Archives
- Brief for Petitioner, Sweatt v. Painter, No. 44, Supreme Court of the United States, October Term 1949 (counsel including Thurgood Marshall and Robert L. Carter), Internet Archive
- Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, 347 U.S. 483 (1954), opinion of Chief Justice Earl Warren, May 17, 1954, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- Mendez v. Westminister School District of Orange County, 64 F. Supp. 544 (S.D. Cal. 1946), opinion of Judge Paul J. McCormick, February 18, 1946, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library