Mendez v. Westminster

Mendez v. Westminster: The Trial

In July 1945 a federal judge in Los Angeles heard five days of testimony about Orange County’s separate schools. What did the parents, the superintendents and the expert witnesses say, and what did the court decide?

6 chapters · 18 min

Chapters

  1. No question of race. Before the first witness spoke, both sides agreed the case was not about race, and the judge doubted a federal court could hear it at all.
  2. The parents testify. Parent after parent described taking a child to the nearer school and being sent to the Mexican one, and the judge listened to how they spoke.
  3. The superintendents. Called as hostile witnesses, the school superintendents gave the court their reasons, and the reasons went beyond language.
  4. Two witnesses for the families. On the last day, an anthropologist and a specialist in teaching minority children told the court that separation slowed the learning the schools said it was meant to serve.
  5. Conclusions of the court. After months of briefs, McCormick ruled that a federal court could act and that equal buildings were not equal protection.
  6. Judgment. The court ordered the four districts to stop, word of the ruling spread, and the districts appealed.

Sources