Ludlow and the Colorado Coalfield War
Ludlow: Ivy Lee and the Bulletins
How did John D. Rockefeller Jr. and his publicity man try to change the public’s mind about Ludlow, and what happened when their facts were tested?
6 chapters · 18 min
Chapters
- The man from the railroad. A month after Ludlow, John D. Rockefeller Jr. asked a railroad publicity man to help tell the coal operators’ side.
- Issued by the Coal Mine Managers. The bulletins carried the names of three Colorado coal men. They were compiled and printed in Philadelphia.
- “No massacre”. One bulletin told the country there had been no massacre at Ludlow, leaving out what the National Guard’s own officers had found.
- Nine weeks. A bulletin made the union’s leaders look rich, but the figures were wrong, and the operators knew it for weeks before they corrected them.
- “Not my own”. Under questioning in Denver and New York, the operators named Lee as the man behind the bulletins, and Lee said the story he told had been theirs.
- The commission’s answer. In Washington the commission printed the letters between Rockefeller and Lee, and its reports answered the bulletins.
Sources
- Industrial Relations: Final Report and Testimony, vol. 7 (Senate Doc. 415, 64th Congress): Denver hearings, testimony of J. F. Welborn, December 5 and 8, 1914, Internet Archive (Prelinger Library)
- Industrial Relations: Final Report and Testimony, vol. 8 (Senate Doc. 415, 64th Congress): New York hearings, testimony of John D. Rockefeller Jr. (January 25, 1915) and Ivy L. Lee (January 27–28, 1915), Internet Archive (Prelinger Library)
- Industrial Relations: Final Report and Testimony, vol. 9 (Senate Doc. 415, 64th Congress): Washington hearings, May 1915, testimony of Rockefeller and Lee, and the Lee Exhibit (Rockefeller–Lee correspondence, 1914), Internet Archive (Prelinger Library)
- Industrial Relations: Final Report and Testimony, vol. 1: Report of Basil M. Manly, signed by Commissioners Walsh, Lennon, O’Connell and Garretson, Internet Archive (Prelinger Library)
- Facts Concerning the Struggle in Colorado for Industrial Freedom, Series I (Bulletins 1–15 and summary), issued by the Committee of Coal Mine Managers, Internet Archive (University of California Libraries)
- Facts Concerning the Struggle in Colorado for Industrial Freedom, Series I (dated bulletins), Internet Archive (Cornell University Library)
- George P. West, Report on the Colorado Strike, United States Commission on Industrial Relations, Internet Archive (Bancroft Library)
- Ludlow: Being the Report of the Special Board of Officers, Colorado National Guard (dated May 2, 1914), Internet Archive (Bancroft Library)
- John A. Fitch, “Law and Order: The Issue in Colorado,” The Survey, vol. 33, no. 10, Internet Archive
- “The End of the Colorado Coal Strike,” The Survey, vol. 33, no. 12, Internet Archive
- The operators’ correction of the salary figures, as printed in The Survey, vol. 33, no. 17, Internet Archive
- “Probing the Causes of Unrest,” no. 19, The Survey, vol. 33, no. 19, Internet Archive
- Report of the Washington hearings, The Survey, vol. 34, no. 10, Internet Archive
- LEE, IVY L. (Harris & Ewing glass negative, LCCN 2016860103), Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division, via Wikimedia Commons
- J.D. Rockefeller, Jr. on stand, 1/25/15 (Bain News Service, LCCN 2014698265), Library of Congress, George Grantham Bain Collection, via Wikimedia Commons