The Lavender Scare and the 1965 Pickets
The Lavender Scare: The Pickets
Shut out of federal work, Kameny and the Mattachine Society of Washington wrote letters, testified, sued and finally picketed. How did the government respond, and what had changed in its rules by 1975 and by 1995?
7 chapters · 21 min
Chapters
- A society in Washington. A new society in Washington, with Kameny named in the papers as its president, began writing to the government that had shut gay people out.
- A bill aimed at one society. A congressman tried to take away the Society’s permit to raise money, and the House of Representatives voted for his bill.
- Onto the sidewalk. Picketing was talked about for two years before it began, and a court ruling that summer gave the pickets a new argument.
- Summer of signs. Small, orderly picket lines appeared at the Civil Service Commission, the White House and the State Department, and the government took notes on all of them.
- October 23, 1965. The largest of the year’s White House pickets drew people from five places, and the organizers and the FBI counted them differently.
- The Commission answers. The Civil Service Commission finally met with the Society, then answered in writing that its policy would stand.
- A rule changed, clearances unchanged. A 1969 court ruling and a 1975 rule narrowed the ban on federal jobs, but security clearances were covered by a separate order until 1995.
Sources
- FBI headquarters file 100-403320, Mattachine Society, 1948-1971 (FOIA release), including copies of Eastern Mattachine Magazine (1965), FBI memoranda of April 2 and October 25, 1965, Philadelphia teletypes of 1966 and July 4, 1967, and the Civil Service Commission’s letter of February 25, 1966, Internet Archive
- FBI Washington Field Office file on the Mattachine Society of Washington (FOIA release), including the Society’s statement “Discrimination Against the Employment of Homosexuals” (February 28, 1963) and reports on the 1965 pickets, Internet Archive
- Congressional Record (bound edition), vol. 110, part 14, House of Representatives, August 11, 1964: debate and vote on H.R. 5990, amending the District of Columbia Charitable Solicitation Act, U.S. Government Publishing Office, GovInfo
- Scott v. Macy, 349 F.2d 182 (D.C. Cir. 1965), opinion of Chief Judge Bazelon, June 16, 1965, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- LGBTQ protest sign, 1965-1967 (catalog no. 2006.0223.09), associated with Frank Kameny, Kameny Papers Project, catalog record, National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution
- “Government Policy toward Homosexuals Creates Security Risks” picket sign (catalog no. 2006.0223.02), associated with Frank Kameny, Kameny Papers Project, catalog record, National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution
- Poster, “Discrimination Against Homosexuals Is As Immoral As Discrimination Against Negros & Jews” (catalog no. 2006.0223.12), Kameny Papers Project, catalog record, National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution
- Norton v. Macy, 417 F.2d 1161 (D.C. Cir. 1969), opinion of Chief Judge Bazelon, July 1, 1969, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- Civil Service Commission, Federal Employment: Revised Basis for Disqualification and Dismissal (proposed rule, 5 CFR Part 731), Federal Register vol. 38, no. 231 (December 3, 1973), pp. 33315-33316, U.S. Government Publishing Office, GovInfo
- Civil Service Commission, Part 731, Suitability: Revised Basis for Disqualification and Dismissal (final rule), Federal Register vol. 40, no. 129 (July 3, 1975), pp. 28047-28048, U.S. Government Publishing Office, GovInfo
- Executive Order 12968, Access to Classified Information, August 2, 1995, Federal Register vol. 60, no. 151 (August 7, 1995), pp. 40245-40254, U.S. Government Publishing Office, GovInfo
- Executive Order 10450, Security Requirements for Government Employment, April 27, 1953, Federal Register vol. 18, no. 82 (April 29, 1953), pp. 2489-2493, U.S. Government Publishing Office, GovInfo