The Lavender Scare and the 1965 Pickets
The Lavender Scare: Kameny v. Brucker
In 1957 the Army fired the astronomer Franklin Kameny and the Civil Service Commission barred him from federal work. What reasons did the government put in writing, what did Kameny answer, and how far did his case go?
6 chapters · 18 min
Chapters
- An astronomer for the Army. Franklin Kameny had fought in the war and then studied the stars. In 1957 the Army hired him as an astronomer, as long as he passed a background check.
- San Francisco, August 1956. The government and Kameny gave different accounts of the arrest, and the court papers kept both.
- Two interviews. Civil Service Commission investigators told Kameny they had information that he was gay, and he refused to answer questions about his private life.
- Two reasons on paper. The Army fired Kameny for falsifying his application, and the Civil Service Commission barred him from all federal jobs for immoral conduct.
- In the courts. Kameny sued to get his job back, and the courts ruled on the Army’s procedure without ruling on the Commission’s finding.
- Petitioner, pro se. Kameny wrote his own petition to the Supreme Court and said that the government’s treatment of gay Americans was discrimination as wrong as any other.
Sources
- Kameny v. Brucker, No. 15,596, U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit: Brief for Appellant (Byron N. Scott), Joint Appendix, Brief for Appellees (Oliver Gasch, U.S. Attorney, et al.) and Petition for Rehearing (filed July 1960); scanned at Georgetown University Law Library, Internet Archive
- Kameny v. Brucker, 282 F.2d 823 (D.C. Cir. 1960), per curiam, June 23, 1960, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- Case File 676, October Term 1960: Petition for Writ of Certiorari, Kameny v. Brucker (Franklin Edward Kameny, pro se; received January 27, 1961), with the motion for extension of time, the printed joint appendix, docket card and clerk’s correspondence, Records of the Supreme Court of the United States (RG 267), National Archives
- Kameny v. Brucker, Secretary of the Army, et al., 365 U.S. 843 (1961), certiorari denied, March 20, 1961, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- Franklin E. Kameny to President John F. Kennedy, May 15, 1961 (copy), Papers of John F. Kennedy, White House Central Name File, National Archives