Philadelphia, 1793

Philadelphia, 1793: The Reply

When Mathew Carey’s history of the fever accused Black nurses of extortion, how did Absalom Jones and Richard Allen answer him, and what changed?

7 chapters · 22 min

Chapters

  1. This trifle. Mathew Carey wrote a history of the epidemic while it was ending, and it sold so fast that he printed four editions in two months.
  2. The vilest of the blacks. Carey praised Jones, Allen and Gray by name, and in the same paragraph accused unnamed Black nurses of extortion and of stealing from the houses of the sick.
  3. A refutation. Jones and Allen printed a reply that answered Carey’s charges with accounts, prices and the conduct of white nurses.
  4. An ill name. Jones and Allen explained why a single paragraph mattered so much to free Black Philadelphians.
  5. The fourth edition. Carey revised the paragraph in January 1794, but kept its charge and called the immunity error useful.
  6. Having been ourselves slaves. Jones and Allen ended their pamphlet with an argument against slavery and words to Black readers, enslaved and free.
  7. Two churches. Within months of the fever, Jones and Allen each opened a Black church in Philadelphia.

Sources