Chinese Exclusion and Wong Kim Ark
Chinese Exclusion: The Certificates
After 1882, the right of a Chinese laborer to live in the United States came down to a paper. What happened when the government cancelled those papers and then demanded new ones?
7 chapters · 21 min
Chapters
- A certificate for Chae Chan Ping. A San Francisco laborer left for China in 1887 carrying the paper the law said would bring him home.
- Void and of no effect. A new law cancelled every return certificate at once, and a federal court said the hardship to men already at sea was no concern of the courts.
- Vast hordes. The Supreme Court agreed that the act broke two treaties and upheld it anyway, in words about race that the court would repeat in later cases.
- The Chinese must stay. A month before the decision, a Chinese writer answered the charges against his people, one by one, in a national magazine.
- One credible white witness. In 1892 Congress made every Chinese laborer carry a certificate of residence, and a man without one could prove his right to stay only through a white witness.
- Arrested on May 6. On the day after the deadline, three Chinese laborers in New York were arrested, and within nine days the Supreme Court had upheld the law that took them.
- Why do they send missionaries?. Three justices dissented from the decision, and one of them was Stephen J. Field, the author of the 1889 opinion that upheld exclusion.
Sources
- In re Chae Chan Ping, no. 10100, case file, U.S. Circuit Court for the Northern District of California, with his custom-house return certificate of June 2, 1887, and the court’s findings and opinion of October 1888, National Archives at San Francisco
- Act of October 1, 1888, chapter 1064 (the Scott Act), United States Statutes at Large, vol. 25, p. 504, Internet Archive
- Chae Chan Ping v. United States (the Chinese Exclusion Case), 130 U.S. 581, decided May 13, 1889, United States Reports, vol. 130, Internet Archive
- Yan Phou Lee, “The Chinese Must Stay,” North American Review, vol. 148, no. 389 (April 1889), pp. 476–483, Internet Archive
- Fong Yue Ting v. United States, 149 U.S. 698, decided May 15, 1893, with the text of the Act of May 5, 1892, United States Reports, vol. 149, Internet Archive
- Assignment of Duplicate Certificate of Residence to Chu Fong, with enclosed certificate of residence No. 120975 (April 16, 1894) and his affidavit of 1901, Chinese General Correspondence, Records of the Immigration and Naturalization Service, National Archives
- Compilation from the Records of the Bureau of Immigration of Facts Concerning the Enforcement of the Chinese-Exclusion Laws (Government Printing Office, 1906), Internet Archive