Eunice Hunton Carter and the Case Against Luciano
How did the one Black woman on a ten-person prosecution staff build the theory that convicted the country’s most powerful mob boss?
13 chapters · 28 min
Chapters
- The Hunton Family in Atlanta. Carter was born into a family of national Black organizers, and her own path into public life started with theirs.
- Addie Hunton’s War. While Eunice was a young woman in the United States, her mother sailed for France as one of only three Black women sent to support the 200,000 Black soldiers serving in a segregated American army.
- Smith College and a Marriage in Harlem. Carter earned two degrees from Smith College in four years, then built a first career in social work and a household in Harlem, before any thought of law.
- Fordham Law by Night. Carter studied law in Fordham’s evening program while working full time, and passed the New York bar at a point in life when most lawyers are already years into practice.
- A Run for the Assembly. A year before Dewey ever appointed her, Carter ran for elected office herself, as the Republican nominee for a Harlem Assembly seat, and lost.
- One Woman on Dewey’s Staff. Governor Lehman appointed Thomas Dewey to go after organized crime in New York, and Carter was the only Black attorney and, by the clearest account located, the only woman on his staff.
- The Pattern in the Bail Books. Carter noticed that prostitution cases across the city kept running through the same small set of bondsmen and lawyers, and argued that meant a single organization, not scattered independent operators, was behind them.
- Wiretaps and an Index. Dewey’s office did not take Carter’s theory on faith; it tested it, with wiretaps on the bondsmen her pattern had flagged and a citywide index built to tie the results together.
- Trial and Conviction. Luciano went to trial on the theory Carter helped build, was convicted, and received one of the longest sentences of its kind in the state’s history, while Carter herself had no formal role in the courtroom proceedings.
- The Women’s Court Years. Carter’s own career continued for roughly a decade after the Luciano trial, in an office whose own records disagree on exactly which post she held.
- Private Practice and Geneva. After leaving government work, Carter built a second career through civic groups, and later chaired a body of such groups working with the United Nations.
- Family and a Grandson’s Book. Carter’s only child built his own career in federal government, and it was her grandson, decades after her death, who brought her role in the Luciano case back into public view.
- A Fictional Version, and the Real One. A television character modeled on Carter struck some viewers as made up. That reaction says as much about how forgotten the real history had become as it does about the show.
Sources
- Eunice Hunton Carter, Historical Society of the New York Courts
- Invisible: The Forgotten Story of the Black Woman Lawyer Who Took Down America’s Most Powerful Mobster, Stephen L. Carter, Henry Holt, 2018; catalog record via Library of Congress
- Eunice Hunton Carter: A Lifelong Fight for Social Justice, Marilyn S. Greenwald and Yun Li, Fordham University Press, 2021
- Eunice Carter, Fordham University School of Law, Alumni of Distinction
- The Real-Life Heroine Who Inspired a Character on ‘Boardwalk Empire’, Fordham University School of Law News
- Addie Waites Hunton, Wikipedia, cross-checked against cited sources
- Lisle C. Carter, Wikipedia, cross-checked against cited sources
- National Council of Negro Women, University of Virginia, Carter G. Woodson Institute Black Leadership project
- Lucky Luciano leaving court after sentencing, Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division
- Photo postcard of Addie Waites Hunton and Kathryn M. Johnson at a YMCA camp, Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture
- New York State Assembly chamber, Albany, Wikimedia Commons
- Palais des Nations, United Nations, Geneva, Wikimedia Commons