The Cherokee and Removal
The Cherokee and Removal: The Court and the Treaty
The Cherokee won in the Supreme Court in 1832. How, four years later, did a treaty most of them rejected become law?
7 chapters · 19 min
Chapters
- Not the tribunal. The Cherokee took Georgia to the Supreme Court, and the Court answered that it had no power to hear their case.
- The oath. Georgia arrested white missionaries who would not swear loyalty to the state, and two of them refused to give in.
- A distinct community. This time the Supreme Court ruled for the Cherokee and declared that the laws of Georgia had no force anywhere inside their nation.
- “Now let him enforce it”. Georgia ignored the Supreme Court, and the famous line blaming Jackson first appears in print thirty-two years later.
- Two delegations. Worn down by Georgia’s laws, the Cherokee leaders split over whether to sign away the land.
- New Echota. A small group signed away the whole Cherokee homeland, and the treaty said they had the people’s authority.
- “No treaty at all”. Cherokee across the nation protested, an army officer called the treaty a fraud, and the Senate ratified it by one vote.
Sources
- Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 30 U.S. (5 Peters) 1 (1831), opinion of Chief Justice Marshall, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School
- Worcester v. Georgia, 31 U.S. (6 Peters) 515 (1832), opinion of Chief Justice Marshall and judgment, Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School
- Case File for Worcester v. Georgia, Records of the Supreme Court of the United States (RG 267), National Archives
- Horace Greeley, The American Conflict, vol. 1 (Hartford, 1864), p. 106 and note, Internet Archive
- James Mooney, Myths of the Cherokee, Nineteenth Annual Report of the Bureau of American Ethnology (Government Printing Office, 1900), historical sketch, Internet Archive
- Treaty Between the United States and the Cherokee Indians Signed at New Echota, Georgia, December 29, 1835, General Records of the U.S. Government (RG 11), National Archives
- Cherokee Petition in Protest of the New Echota Treaty, from the citizens of the Aquohee and Taquoe districts, 1836, Records of the U.S. Senate (RG 46), National Archives