The Bisbee Deportation, 1917

The Bisbee Deportation: The Commission, the Trial and the Court

How did the federal government, Arizona’s courts and the Supreme Court respond to the Bisbee deportation, and why was no one punished?

6 chapters · 11 min

Chapters

  1. “A golden date”. Bisbee’s newspaper and business leaders celebrated the deportation and defended it to the President.
  2. The commission’s verdict. President Wilson’s Mediation Commission found the deportation unwarranted and without authority in law.
  3. Indicted. A federal grand jury indicted leading men of the district for conspiracy to deprive citizens of their rights.
  4. The law of necessity. In an Arizona kidnapping trial, the defense argued that the deportation was justified by necessity, and the judge let them try.
  5. Acquitted. The jury acquitted Wootton on its first ballot, and the county later dropped every remaining case.
  6. United States v. Wheeler. The Supreme Court ruled that the federal government had no power to punish private citizens who drove other citizens out of a state.

Sources