The Bisbee Deportation, 1917
The Bisbee Deportation: The Commission, the Trial and the Court
How did the federal government, Arizona’s courts and the Supreme Court respond to the Bisbee deportation, and why was no one punished?
6 chapters · 11 min
Chapters
- “A golden date”. Bisbee’s newspaper and business leaders celebrated the deportation and defended it to the President.
- The commission’s verdict. President Wilson’s Mediation Commission found the deportation unwarranted and without authority in law.
- Indicted. A federal grand jury indicted leading men of the district for conspiracy to deprive citizens of their rights.
- The law of necessity. In an Arizona kidnapping trial, the defense argued that the deportation was justified by necessity, and the judge let them try.
- Acquitted. The jury acquitted Wootton on its first ballot, and the county later dropped every remaining case.
- United States v. Wheeler. The Supreme Court ruled that the federal government had no power to punish private citizens who drove other citizens out of a state.
Sources
- Bisbee Daily Review, p. 1, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- “Deportation of I.W.W. Backed Up by Citizens of Warren District”, Bisbee Daily Review, p. 3, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- Daily Kennebec Journal (Augusta, Maine), p. 1, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- “Deportation Found to Be Unnecessary,” summary of the President’s Mediation Commission report, Evening Star (Washington, D.C.), p. 4, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- “Bisbee Citizens Jailed for Deportation of Men”, Circle Banner (Circle, Mont.), p. 2, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- “History of Wootton Case in Arizona,” quoting the Mediation Commission report, Alaska Daily Empire (Juneau), p. 2, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- Arizona Republican (Phoenix), p. 1, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- Tombstone Epitaph, p. 2, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- “Jury Acquits Defendant in Bisbee Trial”, Casper Daily Tribune, p. 1, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- “Bisbee Cases Dismissed”, Great Falls Daily Tribune, p. 2, Library of Congress, Chronicling America
- United States v. Wheeler, 254 U.S. 281 (1920), Library of Congress, United States Reports